The fact that publishing companies are starting to make electronic versions of their books available for the iPhone has recently made the news. Scrollmotion is reported to have made deals with six publishers for books for its Iceberg e-reader for the iPhone, and a few books were available (at prices that were quite high for e-books). Brisingr, by Christopher Paolini, is priced at $27.50, for example (this article lists all the prices).
Random House is also making available, free, for the iPhone the same 9 books that are available for free for the Kindle through February (the list is here). I decided to download and try one of them in the interest of comparing the reading experiences on both platforms: Six Bad Things by Charlie Huston. This is in addition to all the reading I'm doing for Kindle reviews, and for my job. Hence the title of this post.
Six Bad Things is an entertaining and clever suspense story, sort of Elmore Leonard meets Carl Hiassen with a protagonist who is a criminal somewhat redeemed by his pangs of conscience. It's a fairly easy and fun read. I'm using the Stanza e-reader for iPhone as my platform. This platform also has some 40,000 new and popular titles available for sale through Fictionwise, about a fifth of the number of titles available for the Kindle through Amazon. There are also a selection of free offerings, mainly samples and public domain works inlcuding direct access to Project Gutenberg books.
Now to the pros and cons.
Costs. The price of individual books (aside from the free offerings) is higher, sometimes considerably higher, than the price of Kindle books. For example, Twilight by Stephanie Meyer is $6.04 for the Kindle and $10.99 from Fictionwise. The Audacity of Hope by President-elect Barack Obama is $9.99 for the Kindle and $14.95 from Fictionwise. Brisingr is the aforementioned $27.50, but only $9.99 on the Kindle. If you read a lot, you'll save money with the Kindle. [Added 1/1/09:] However, please see this post on lowering these initially higher costs using Fictionwise's discounts and rebates.
On the other hand, the Kindle is an expensive device--$359 if you can find one. The iPhone is also expensive, especially if you factor in the monthly service fee (Amazon does not charge for the Kindle's Whispernet cellular connection), but one could argue that one already has the phone for other purposes, so there's really no additional hardware cost to using it as a book reader. For some readers who already own iPhones anyway and who don't read enough to offset the difference in the cost of books, the Stanza reader and Fictionwise bookstore on the iPhone may be a better deal.
Size: Is it a pro or a con? Well, it's a little of both. Because of its small size, the iPhone, unlike the Kindle, fits in a pocket. It's the ebook that you'll always have with you and can be held comfortably in one hand. It has a relatively generous screen, for a phone. Yet, of course, even a large cell phone screen is small compared to the Kindle. Thus, the font is either small and needs to be held right in front of one's nose, or it is large and only a few words fit on the page, requiring frequent page refreshes, frustrating if you're a fast reader. After some experimentation, I chose a smallish, but not the smallest, size. On the other hand, the Kindle, while not pocketable, has a screen roughly the size of a paperback book, and also has adjustable fonts. It's more like reading a regular book, while the iPhone, while quite usable for short periods, is a bit small and squinty over long stretches.
Electronic goodies. This one's a bit of a moving target, since both devices and their underlying software programming can be expected to improve over time, possibly in unpredictable ways. While the Stanza reader for iPhone has some decent features, including adjustable font sizes, a basic search, and bookmarks, at this time it does not have all the functionality of the Kindle. One can't make marginal notes and highlight portions of text, and then recall them at will. The best substitute I've found is using a descriptive bookmark system, which isn't as robust. There's no on-device dictionary with the Stanza, although one could just use the web browser on the iPhone to look up words if one is in wireless range.
Screen resolution: according to the tech specs, the Kindle has a very slightly better resolution at 167 ppi vs. 163 ppi for the iPhone. Because of the e-ink technology, the Kindle screen looks more like printed paper, while the iPhone's screen is brighter and, of course, color. Color doesn't make all that much difference for fiction reading, except that the book covers look much nicer, but you know what they say about covers.
Eyes: Admittedly, this is subjective and based only on personal experience. On the Kindle, I can read for hours at a time without a problem, when I have the time--I find no difference between the Kindle and a paper book in that regard. If you're the kind of reader who likes to curl up with a book for a whole afternoon, the Kindle is great (and it also has loads of fancy electronic goodness). After an hour and a half of reading on the iPhone, I started to get eyestrain, and after about 2 hours I had a full-blown headache and had to stop. On the other hand, it could be nice to have an iPhone book in situations where the Kindle isn't as convenient, like waiting in a line or standing in the Metro.
Bottom line: For iPhone owners who read occasionally or for short stretches and want a reading option with them at all times (because we iPhone owners always have our phones), the Stanza reader on iPhone would work. For those who read a lot, who want the book price advantage of Amazon, and who love the experience of reading for long stretches of time and want the conveniences of the built-in dictionary, highlighting, note-taking, instant access to books, and having a library in one device, the Kindle is the way to go.
In the ideal world: I'd be able to put a given e-book on both devices, and synchronize bookmarks between them. Whilst rushing about, I'd read in snatches on the iPhone; whilst relaxing, I'd read on the Kindle. Yeah, like that'll ever happen.